I made a mistake on a payroll that already went out. What should I do?

Updated November 20, 2026

Most mistakes don't need a reversal:

  • Underpaid someone: Run a separate payroll for the difference.
  • Overpaid someone: Recover it on future paychecks with a deduction, or work out repayment with your employee.
  • Paid someone who shouldn't have been paid: Contact support to reverse the payment.
  • Wrong tax withholding: Have the employee update their W-4 so future paychecks are correct. Withholding is an estimate that gets settled when they file their tax return, so reversing payroll is rarely the right fix.
  • Wrong pay period dates: Pay periods are for your records and don't affect taxes. Don't reverse payroll to change them.